Rheumatoid arthritis

Authors:

Dr Penny Hawkins

,  

Dr Rachael Armstrong

,  

Tania Boden

,  

Dr Paul Garside

,  

Katherine Knight

,  

Dr Elliot Lilley

,  

Dr Michael Seed

,  

Dr Michael Wilkinson

,  

Richard O. Williams

,  

Publication:

Inflammopharmacology 23, 131-150

Publish Date: 

22 June 2015

Background

Rheumatoid arthritis is a painful, chronic autoimmune disorder for which animal models are commonly used to research and develop therapies and treatments. However, the procedures used to induce arthritis in animals can cause suffering, which may be mild, moderate or severe, depending upon the model and the duration of the study. Implementation of the 3Rs (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement) is thus a priority.

Summary

This report focuses on identifying causes of suffering in mouse and rat models of rheumatoid arthritis. It proposes practical refinements to alleviate suffering and improve welfare, including around husbandry, protocols (e.g. arthritis inducers and administration) and study duration. The report also addresses other relevant issues, such as minimising variability in studies, the potential for administering pain relief, welfare assessment, humane endpoints, reporting standards, and the potential for replacing animals in rheumatoid arthritis research.

Key Actions

  • Carefully select the most appropriate approach and ‘model’, taking into consideration the scientific, ethical, and animal welfare issues.
  • Implement housing and care refinements that meet the needs of the animals, including appropriate environmental enrichment.
  • Carefully refine the protocol, including handling and restraint methods, choice, volume and frequency of inducers, and study duration.
  • Identify and refine adverse effects, such as the effects of boosting, and those at the different phases of the disease.
  • Design adequate pain relief protocols and ensure appropriate analgesia is administered.
  • Identify suitable welfare indicators such as weight loss, ‘pain faces’, and swollen paws, and develop an effective scoring system for their assessment.
  • Define early humane endpoints.
A white mouse.

Further questions

Authors

Dr Penny Hawkins - RSPCA Animals in Science Department

Dr Rachael Armstrong - Huntingdon Research Centre

Tania Boden - UCB Celltech

Dr Paul Garside - University of Glasgow

Katherine Knight - Home Office, Animals in Science Regulation Unit

Dr Elliot Lilley - RSPCA Animals in Science Department

Dr Michael Seed - University of East London

Dr Michael Wilkinson - University of Glasgow

Dr Richard O. Williams - University of Oxford